The Lowest Part D Premium Is Not Always The Lowest-Cost Plan

Updated: Nov 8
When comparing Medicare Part D plans, it is easy to focus mainly on the monthly premium. Which seems like it would make sense, right? After all, a lower monthly premium payment sounds like the best way to save money.
However, that’s where the confusion usually starts when you realize you are spending more than you expected. The premium is only part of what you may pay for your prescriptions throughout the year. A plan with a low monthly premium could have a higher deductible or higher costs for the medications you take.
That is why it is important to consider what the plan will cost you over the entire year, not just the monthly premium.
What Makes Up The Total Cost of a Part D Plan?
Medicare Part D helps cover prescription drugs. You may have a stand-alone Part D plan or prescription drug coverage through a Medicare Advantage plan.
When it comes to comparing your options, it is important to look at all of the following costs:

Your estimated prescription costs should include any deductible you are expected to pay. By looking at the full year, you can really get a clearer picture of how plans compare to one another.
What Could A Plan Comparison Look Like?
Let’s say someone is comparing three stand-alone Part D plans. Each plan covers their current medications, but the premiums and estimated prescription costs are different.

In the example above, Plan A has the lowest monthly premium at $10. However, its estimated prescription costs are higher, bringing its total yearly cost to $1,320.
Plan B has a higher monthly premium of $30, but its lower estimated prescription costs bring its yearly total to $960. That is an estimated $360 less per year than Plan A.
Plan C has the highest premium at $50 per month. Even with lower prescription costs, its estimated yearly total is $1,080, which is more than Plan B.
These plans are simply examples. Your costs really just depend on your medications, the plan you choose, and the pharmacy you use. The lowest-premium plan may still be the right choice for some people. The key is to compare the total cost based on YOUR needs.
What Else Should You Check Besides Cost?
Before choosing or keeping a plan, take a closer look at how it covers your prescriptions.
Are your medications covered?
Each plan has a list of covered medications called a formulary. Check each prescription, including its dosage and how often you fill it.
Which tier is each medication on?
Plans place medications into cost categories called tiers. A medication on a higher tier may cost you more.
Are there any restrictions?
Some medications may require approval from the plan before they are covered, or there may be limits on the quantity you can receive.
Is your pharmacy in the plan's network?
Some in-network pharmacies are considered preferred pharmacies and may offer lower costs than other participating pharmacies.
Your plan’s coverage and costs can change from year to year. Reviewing your Annual Notice of Change (ANOC) and checking your current medication list can help you spot changes before deciding whether to keep your plan.
Are There Other Ways To Save On Prescriptions?
Prescription saving tools may give you another price to compare costs for your Part D plan. To access the tools listed below, click on the corresponding image or header:
This website lists discounted drug prices from manufacturers that have agreed to a Most Favored Nation (MFN) pricing. For example, the website lists Gonal-F at $252 per pen, compared with a reference U.S. price of about $1,450. Actual savings depend on eligibility and how the price compares with what you currently pay.
With this website, it helps you compare prices in order to pay the lowest amount on your medications. 250+ medications are free, with hundreds more under $9.99. Plus, get discounts on online care and other common healthcare services.
They partner with world-class pharmacies across America to ensure your medicine is available to you at the lowest network price. With BlinkRx, your medicine is always in stock at purchase, always at the lowest network price, and always at your door when you need it.
You can also ask your doctor whether a lower-cost medication is appropriate for you. If you have limited income and resources, Medicare’s Extra Help Program may help pay some Part D costs.
Take Time To Review Your Coverage
Even if your plan worked well this year, it is worth checking whether it will still meet your need next year. Medicare Open Enrollment runs form October 15 through December 7, with changes generally taking effect January 1.
Reviewing your options does not mean you have to switch. It simply gives you the information to decide with confidence.
The following drugs listed are confirmed changes for the year of 2027:

Make sure you are prepared when changes begin to happen!
Get Clarity Before You Decide
At MyHealthGap, I work with clients one-on-one and provide independent guidance based on your healthcare needs, doctors, prescriptions, and budget. I do not receive commissions from insurance companies, so my focus is truly on helping understand your options and choose coverage that fits you.
By clicking the button below, it will take you to the Medicare Open Enrollment page where you can learn about the Part D review services and schedule your appointment now!










Comments